Many years ago, my dad (OB"M) took me to a deli. As I knew that I enjoyed kishke when my mom (AOB"M) had it in the house so I ordered it. If came in a shallow dish, smothered with gravy, nothing like the slice of fried orange stuff that I ate at home. I tried it and it was delish.
At that moment I decided to go on a quest -- I would try kishke at every restaurant I went to and keep a log of all of them so I could authoritatively say which kishke was the best. The problem with this plan was that I was without a car in a city which had only one place that served kishke. My sample size for my conclusions about kishke was 1 with no others on the horizon. Thus endeth the quest.
My dreams of eating and thinking about what I ate were not completely squashed. In fact, this past summer, I decided to go to a bunch of different pizza places in Jerusalem and describe them for you. I enjoyed doing that because I got to eat pizza and, man, I love me some pizza.
Side note -- my English for this piece will be in the conversational mode, and I will be sticking with the rules of SPOKEN English, not formal, written English, so please do not come to me and say "you broke this and that rule". No. I ate pizza. Pizza rules apply.
My goal for this vacation is to eat pizza from a variety of local stores and compile a series of descriptions and discussions regarding said pizza. This will be a sort of "Shpizzar," a walk around town, during which I try pizza. Except without the walking because it isn't July in Jerusalem, but January in Teaneck. So car rides, it is.
Another apology before the fact -- I live in a community which provides an embarrassment of dishes and I am going to limit myself to a single slice of plain pizza and (maybe) water. Level playing field. To do this, I am forgoing other food options. You're welcome. My quest for a good mac and cheese will have to wait. Now, as you know, I have a problem with standard food reviews -- they tell me what the reviewer liked, not what I would like. So for this adventure, I will be judging, describing and opining base on what I like to eat. You may not agree with my assessments, or share my pizza-taste values. I can't help you if you choose to be wrong. But you will have the information with which to go forward and no one can ask more than that, except "one billion dollars." And I'm not asking that, yet.
So here we go. I drove over to Lazy Bean, figuring that if I parked there and walked around, I would end up there and I could go grocery shopping. I'm all about planning. They sell personal pizzas so I asked for one of those. It took about 10 minutes. That's fine. I had to defrost.
The dough is premade. The cheese has a very buttery flavor and there is a good amount of it. But both it and the dough lack any real distinct flavor or character. The pizza is slightly sweet; it has crispy edges but no pizza soul (assuming pizza has a soul, this one didn't have it). The question is whether this entire pizza was premade and frozen and then cooked with some added cheese on it. That cheese provides a reasonable pull/stretch. I imagine that the "bake at home but it tastes like delivery" pizzas taste like this.
When folded, the crust was too thick and chewy. Bottom line, if I found myself at LB and had an insane need for pizza, this would suffice, but it is not a destination pizza.
I walked over to EJ's. In Israel, walking from one pizza place to the next might actually burn a few calories. In Teaneck, the "walk" is shorter than that so I don't get the myriad health benefits that the holy land provides. Also, it is 28 degrees outside. F, that. At EJ's I got the first slice out of a clearly left over pie, reheated. The dough has a strong yeasty flavor and there was very little sauce (though that might be a side effect of the reheating). I tasted some oregano in the sauce. The dough was crispy all the way to the center (an effect of the reheating, I surmise). There was no powerful pizza flavor. This was an OK, but boring slice.
Next stop on the walk was Sammy's. I got a reheated slice there as well. The crust edge has a higher curl than the others, looking more like a traditional slice, and the crust has been dusted with corn meal. The sauce was tangy (though there wasn't a lot of sauce), and the upfront cheese has the buttery flavor. Slice folds well and the crust at the edge is downright fluffy. A really nice slice. Then to Mocha Bleu.
At MB, I had to get a personal pie (I wonder if they trade personal details with LB). It is fancier and served on a little pedestal, hand made to order. The well done crust just screams "garlic" at my nose, and the crust is actually tasty. The cheese has an incredible stretch/pull, but tastes a bit stale. There is too much sauce and cheese and the dough, insubstantial away from the crust, has no presence other than a slight chewiness. In fact, it almost seemed slightly underdone. The salt level is nice. I had to take most of it home because I reached my limit for one morning. Instead of finishing it, I got it packed up and went to the store to get cookies for later. And I got Cinnabon. For "later."
Well, it's later. Bye for now. Tomorrow, I finish the West Englewood area and head over to Cedar Lane, then swing back to the edge of Bergenfield.
Stay tuned. Now I have to go lie down. And eat Cinnabon.